When you buy through our links, Business Insider may earn an affiliate commission. Learn moreAchieving a restaurant-quality crust at home comes down to thermal mass. We churned out dozens of pizzas and loaves of bread in standard home ovens to find the absolute best pizza stones and steels.Lauren Savoie/Business InsiderFibraMent's stone stands out for its versatility and large baking surface for various goods.The Original Baking Steel excels in rapid heat transfer, producing bubbly, browned pizza crusts.Lodge Cast Iron Pizza Pan is ideal for grilling, offering good heat transfer and easy handling.Achieving a blistering, restaurant-quality pizza crust in your home oven requires high, sustained heat that a sheet pan can't deliver. Pizza stones and steels solve this problem by absorbing heat and transferring it directly into the dough, mimicking the effects of a commercial brick or wood fire pizza oven.To find the absolute best options, the BI Reviews team put top-rated cordierte, ceramic, steel, and cast iron stones through hands-on testing. We baked thin-crust pizzas, tested no-knead bread recipes, evaluated grill performance — on gas and charcoal grills — and measured thermal retention.We also hit up experts to get their top tips and tricks for making pizza at home. After weeks of rigorous testing, consultations with pizza expert Andrew Janjigian, and eating more slices than we can count, a few clear winners emerged from the pack. The winners at a glanceBest overall: FibraMent Home Oven Baking Stone - See at AmazonBest budget: Solido 14x16 Cordierite Pizza Stone - See at AmazonBest steel: The Original Baking Steel - See at Baking SteelBest for the grill: Lodge Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan - See at Amazon Our top picks include a cast-iron workhorse that really cooks on an outdoor grill, a conductive steel model for rapid bakes and crust blistering, and a corderite slab that handles pizza and bread with ease.Find out more about how Insider Reviews tests and reviews kitchen products.Our top picks for the best pizza stoneBest overall: FibraMent Home Oven Baking Stone 20x15 - See at AmazonFibraMent's stone is built for maximum versatility: it features a wide baking surface that can accommodate all sizes of baked goods, 3/4 inch thickness for durability, and balanced heat transfer that makes both exceptional pizzas and well-baked bread.Best budget: Solido 14x16 Cordierite Pizza Stone - See at AmazonThis cordierite pizza stone bakes good pizza, but also produces excellent bread, making it a great choice for those looking for a solid pizza stone on a budget.Best steel: The Original Baking Steel - See at Baking SteelIf you want to make the best, most bubbly, and well-browned pizza, The Original Baking Steel produces a crust like no other and is easy to move, clean, and use. Best for the grill: Lodge 15 Inch Seasoned Cast Iron Pizza Pan - See at AmazonThis round cast-iron stone has handles for easy maneuvering and is perfectly sized and shaped for making pizza on both charcoal and gas grills.Pizza stone versus pizza steel: Which material is right for you?When testing the best pizza stones, we evaluated models made from steel, ceramic/cordierite, and cast iron. The secret to a great pizza crust all comes down to thermal mass and conductivity — essentially, how much heat a material can hold and how fast it transfers that heat to your dough. Because these materials have different thermal properties, they serve different purposes in the kitchen.Pizza steels are best for ultimate pizza crusts: Steel absorbs and transfers heat incredibly fast. When heated to 500 degrees in a standard home oven, a steel behaves similarly to the surface of a commercial brick oven. This rapid, intense heat transfer creates the immediate "oven spring" bubbling and charred leopard spotting that are signs of restaurant-quality pizza. If you will just be using it to make pizza, we recommend a steel, like The Original Baking Steel.Ceramic and cordierite stones are best for versatility and bread baking: Because cordierite and ceramic have less thermal mass and lower conductivity than steel, they transfer heat more slowly. While this means your pizza crust might turn out paler than it would be on a steel, it makes these materials ideal for baking bread. The slower heat transfer ensures the bottom of a thick loaf of sourdough won't burn before the center finishes baking. If you want a multitasker for both pizza and bread, our best overall pick, the FibraMent Home Oven Baking Stone, or our budget pick, the Solido 14×16 Cordierite Pizza Stone are both great choices.Cast iron pizza stones are best used on the grill: Cast iron offers a happy medium, sitting right between steel and ceramic in terms of heat conductivity. While finding a rectangular cast-iron pizza stone is nearly impossible — most options on the market are circular — this shape is a huge advantage once it comes time to grill. Rectangular stones often don't fit
Don't miss out on breaking stories and in-depth articles.
